Plan the perfect garden with our interactive tool →

How to Identify Edible Chestnuts

Jupiterimages/ Images


Do not confuse edible chestnuts with horse chestnuts or buckeyes, which are both inedible.

A Chinese chestnut tree is not the same thing as a water chestnut. A water chestnut is a native Asian aquatic plant with corms on the roots that are harvested and used in many Asian dishes.

There are four different varieties of edible chestnuts: American, European, Chinese and Japanese. The chestnut tree is related to the beech and the oak tree. Chestnuts used to be the main starch staple in Europe until the potato was introduced. When edible chestnuts are boiled the nuts have a similar texture to potatoes, with a sweet nutty flavor. Now chestnuts are not as popular as they once were, but there are commercial farms to supply the demand. Mature American chestnut trees are rare in the wild due to infestation by the chestnut blight in the early 20th century.

To identify an edible chestnut in the wild is not very hard; you just need to know what you are looking for. Impostors such as horse chestnuts and Ohio buckeyes, though similar in appearance, are not related to edible chestnuts; these seeds contain a poison in their raw state, so it is important to be able to distinguish them from edible chestnuts.

John Foxx/Stockbyte/Getty Images

Identify the tree that the chestnut has fallen from as a chestnut tree. It will have long oval leaves that are yellowish green, and yellow in the fall. On the leaves there will be small hooks that curve up all along the edge of the leaf. Ohio buckeye trees have similar leaves, but the buckeye leaves are usually grouped together in a fan of five leaves and turn orange in the fall. A horse chestnut tree has a rounder shaped leaf, and these leaves group together in a fan of about seven leaves.

Jupiterimages/ Images

Observe how the fruit hangs from the tree. Edible chestnuts often hang in pairs or in threes or clusters.

Michael Blann/Photodisc/Getty Images

Look at the casing the chestnut is wrapped in when hanging on the tree. An edible chestnut is wrapped in a spiny case that is called a burr. The spines are long and fine. If it is an Ohio buckeye, the outer casing has many thick, knobby spurs. A horse chestnut's shell resembles the Ohio buckeye's but it does not have as many spurs.

Jupiterimages/ Images

Remove the chestnut from the burr and look at the shape of the fruit. An edible chestnut will have a shiny brown color, a flat bottom and a point on the top. Non-edible chestnuts will not have this point at the top.

Garden Guides